And, oh hey, look what I found when browsing around for "Old Skool" on the Smart Bitches site (I believe they may have coined the "Old Skool" tag): a challenge! I guess great trashy minds think alike. Heh. Lots of good ideas in the comments there for Old Skool favorites.
Skye O'Malley, by Bertrice Small
The Wildest Heart, by Rosemary Rodgers
Captive Passions, by Fern Michaels (this is a slight cheat, because I didn't actually re-read for the review, but it's certainly in the spirit of the feature)
Shanna, by Kathleen Woodiwiss
Scruples, by Judith Krantz